Card grading: PSA, BGS, SGC and CGC compared

    Updated 16 November 2026 8 min

    Grading means sending a card to an independent company that authenticates it, scores its condition and seals it in a tamper-evident holder. A graded card is easier to sell at distance because the buyer no longer has to trust photos. It also costs money and time, so it is not the right choice for every card.

    How grading works

    You submit the card with a declared value and a service level. The company checks that the card is genuine and unaltered, examines it under magnification, assigns a grade and encapsulates it in a sealed plastic holder, known as a slab, with a label and a certification number.

    That number can be looked up on the grader's website. It is the first thing to check when buying a slab: the card, the grade and the label in the listing must match the record.

    What graders look at

    Chrome cards are unforgiving. Their mirror surface shows every flaw, which is why gem grades are harder to reach than on paper stock.

    1. 1Centering: how evenly the image sits between the borders, front and back.
    2. 2Corners: four sharp points under magnification, no whitening or soft tips.
    3. 3Edges: no chipping or roughness along the cut.
    4. 4Surface: no scratches, print lines, dimples or fingerprints in the coating.

    The PSA scale

    PSA grades from 1 to 10. Modern cards pulled from a pack and handled carefully mostly land between 8 and 10, so the gap that matters for recent football cards is the one between PSA 9 and PSA 10.

    • 10Gem Mint
    • 9Mint
    • 8Near Mint-Mint
    • 7Near Mint
    • 6Excellent-Mint
    • 5Excellent
    • 4Very Good-Excellent
    • 3Very Good
    • 2Good
    • 1Poor

    Modern pack-fresh cards almost all land between 8 and 10. PSA also awards half points between 1.5 and 8.5.

    PSA, BGS, SGC, CGC: the differences

    PSA is the most widely traded label for football cards, which usually means the largest pool of buyers and the easiest price comparison.

    BGS (Beckett) grades in half points and can print four subgrades on the label: centering, corners, edges and surface. A BGS 9.5 is its Gem Mint. Its 10 is called Pristine, and a card with four perfect subgrades receives the Black Label, the rarest outcome in the hobby.

    SGC is known for its black insert holder and for consistent turnaround. CGC Cards grades on a 10 point scale with a Pristine 10 above its Gem Mint 10. Newer companies such as TAG grade with computer vision and publish a detailed report for each card.

    For resale, the practical question is which label buyers of that particular card trust and pay for. Check recent sold prices for the same card in each holder before choosing.

    When grading is worth it

    Add the grading fee, shipping both ways, insurance and any customs handling. Then compare the recent sold prices of the card raw, in a 9 and in a 10. Grading makes sense when the likely grade adds clearly more than the total cost.

    Collectors outside the United States should factor in international shipping and import charges on the way back, or use a submission service based in their own country that consolidates orders.

    1. 1Good candidates: numbered parallels, autographs, key rookie cards, cards with clean centering.
    2. 2Poor candidates: base cards of common players, cards with visible print lines or off-centre cuts.
    3. 3Inspect before you send: a loupe and a bright lamp catch most surface flaws.

    Frequently asked questions

    What does PSA 10 mean?

    PSA 10, called Gem Mint, is the highest PSA grade: a card with sharp corners, clean edges, a flawless surface and centering within PSA's tolerance.

    Is BGS 9.5 the same as PSA 10?

    Both are the Gem Mint level of their company, but the market prices them separately. Compare recent sales of the exact card in each holder.

    Can a graded card be fake?

    Counterfeit holders exist. Verify the certification number on the grader's website and compare the card and label with the record before paying.

    Put it into practice

    Browse the catalogue and spot parallels, print runs and grades on real cards.

    Explore the catalogue